Sometimes a service that is on the page does not turn up in the week. Raise it early, and remember that you will be working with these people for years. This chapter is about any difficult conversation, so its examples are neighbors and housemates, and the method carries over: choose a calm time, say what happened, how it affected your child and what you would like, and keep to the one issue.
Opening the conversation: timing, a gentle start, and describing without blame
Choose a time and a medium for a reason, then open by describing what happened, how it affected you and what you would like, one issue at a time.
Start here Essentials
This chapter asks for one thing at minimum: an opening line you could say in under a minute, with a time and place to say it. The steps below work for one conversation with one person, such as a housemate. A position is what you ask for; an interest is why it matters to you, and What you want and why shows how to find yours. You do not need the interests written down to open, but you will want them close by.
- Pick a time. Not right after it happened, not late at night, and not after months of saying nothing. Read Choose the time.
- Write your opening as three parts. What happened, how it affected you, and what you would like. See Describe without blame.
- Take out the all-or-nothing words and any label for the person. Start gently explains why, and the draft check will list them.
- Keep to this one issue. Leave the rest for another day. See One issue at a time.
Minimum time: about 20 minutes. Done when: the conversation plan has an opening line with no "always", "never" or label for the person, and a time and place.
Choose the time Understand
When you raise a disagreement matters almost as much as how. Three timing mistakes show up in the sources we read, and they pull in opposite directions.
The first mistake is raising it right after it happened. Bellevue, Washington's neighborhood mediation program, in a guide on noise, advises against knocking on a door right after being woken by the noise (City of Bellevue's neighborhood noise guide). The same guide warns against the opposite mistake: waiting through months of mounting frustration. In between sits a time when you are calm enough to describe rather than accuse, and early enough that the other person can still change something without feeling ambushed. Several extension and university sheets for roommates make the same point: raise a problem early, before it grows into a list of grievances (a Georgia university roommate agreement) (a Texas university roommate guide). Convention
The second mistake is choosing a moment when one of you has no room to listen: in the doorway on the way to work, in front of other people, or in the middle of dinner. Pick a time when both of you can talk without a clock. If you are not sure the other person has the time, ask: "Is this a good time to talk about the dishes, or would tonight be better?" That sentence is also a request, and it gives the other person a say in the timing.
The third mistake is talking late at night when that has gone badly before. The American Psychological Association suggests that if your arguments tend to happen at night, you change when you discuss important matters (APA on controlling anger). Preference The reason is practical: tired people have less patience, and a conversation that starts badly tends to end that way. The Gottman Institute, a couples research and training group, says discussions tend to end on the same note they begin (Gottman Institute on softening your start). The claim needs a caution, given below.
Assume they may not know
One line in the Bellevue guide is worth carrying into every disagreement: assume the other person does not know and would like to be told. That assumption changes the tone of the opening. If the person genuinely does not know that their dishes pile up, that their dog barks at six, or that the invoice does not match the text, then telling them is a favor and not an accusation. If they do know, you lose nothing by opening as if they did not, because an open door is easier to walk through than a defended one. Preference
Say that you want to talk, then say when
A short invitation takes the surprise out of the conversation. "I'd like to talk about how we handle the kitchen. Do you have twenty minutes tonight or tomorrow?" tells the person the topic, the size of the ask and that they have a choice. It does not tell them what you think they did wrong. Hold the opening line itself for when you sit down. Compare "Can we talk? It's important" sent at noon to someone who then spends the day wondering what they did: the invitation should name the topic.
If you have decided you are too angry to open gently, stop here and read Cooling down. A break of at least 20 minutes, with a time to come back, is part of the plan and not a failure of it. If the other person has hurt you, threatened you, or you are afraid of how they will react when you raise this, the opening steps in this chapter do not apply. Read When Learn Conflict Management is the wrong tool.
Start gently
A start-up is the first minute of a conversation: the sentences that set its tone. The Gottman Institute distinguishes a harsh start-up, which opens with blame or sarcasm, from a soft one, which describes the problem and what you need. It gives a workplace example. The soft version says the work was needed sooner and that you agreed on a deadline for yesterday. The harsh version asks whether the person could, for once, get something done on time (Gottman Institute on softening your start). Both say the work is late. Only the second says something about the person.
The Institute's advice for the soft version has three parts: complain without blaming, use "I" statements, and say what you need (Gottman Institute on the antidotes to the four patterns). For the last part it suggests two questions to ask yourself before you speak: what do I feel, and what do I need? Convention
A word of caution about the evidence. The Institute says its claim that conversations end as they begin comes from a six-year study that predicted divorce from the first three minutes of a conflict talk, but the page does not name the study. We use the idea as practical advice and not as a measured law: a gentle start gives the talk a better chance, and a harsh one makes a defensive reply more likely. The percentage figures attached to this claim appear in the Go deeper section of When it heats up beside the critique of them.
Two words to take out
Both the American Psychological Association and Mayo Clinic advise against all-or-nothing words in a complaint (APA on controlling anger) (Mayo Clinic's anger management tips). APA says that "never" and "always" tend to make your own anger feel justified and to alienate the person you are talking to. Mayo gives a matched pair: "I'm upset that you left the table without offering to help with the dishes" in place of "You never do any housework." The first describes one evening. The second is a verdict on a person, and the person can win the argument by remembering one time they did the housework.
The fix is to be specific about time: "most weeknights this month" is a pattern you can count, and "on Tuesday" is an event. Specific claims can be checked by both of you. All-or-nothing claims can only be denied. Principle
Keep the other person's character out of it
Labels such as lazy, rude, selfish and careless describe a person and not a behavior. Gottman's group calls complaints that blame the person's character criticism, and it is the first of four patterns it says predict trouble in a relationship (When it heats up covers all four). The alternative it recommends is a complaint about one specific action (Gottman Institute on the four patterns).
Describe without blame
Three published scripts help you build the opening. They overlap, and you do not need to pick the "right" one. All of them ask you to describe before you judge.
The I-message
Gordon Training International, the organization founded by Dr. Thomas Gordon, who created I-messages, teaches three parts: a brief, non-blaming description of the behavior you find unacceptable; your feeling; and the concrete effect of the behavior on you (Gordon Training on the three parts of an I-message). Their example to a receptionist runs: when you are not here by 8:30, I am upset, because I have to leave my work to cover the phones. They add that stating only how you feel is an incomplete confrontation, since the person is left to guess what to change. They also warn that the first few times you try it, it will feel self-conscious and a bit mechanical. That is normal, and it passes with use.
The extension version
Oklahoma State University's extension fact sheet, written for co-parents, adds a part: when (event), I feel (feeling), next time I would like (what you want). It also offers an optional fourth part, a consequence if the behavior continues, which it says is mainly for use with children (Oklahoma State extension on "I" messages). We leave the consequence out of the default opening. Making a clear request explains why, and the Go deeper section below sets the consequence step beside the other scripts. The fact sheet is honest about the limit: I-messages do not reliably improve the behavior, but the other person may be more likely to listen.
An empathy statement first
Union College's counseling center teaches a three-part assertive statement. It begins with an empathy statement that recognizes the other person's needs, then states your own needs, then proposes a way to resolve it. Its roommate example ends with: "Can we talk about this and try to come up with a solution?" (Union College on assertiveness) The empathy statement is the part people skip, and it earns its place when you do know something about the other person's situation: "I know you get home late and you're tired." The handout adds that assertiveness does not guarantee the other person will respond as you hope.
Observations, not evaluations
A good description is one a camera could record. Nonviolent Communication, the method developed by Marshall Rosenberg, calls this an observation: what you see or hear, free of judgment or analysis, tied to a time and context (a handout on the four components of NVC). Compare "You left a mess" (an evaluation) with "There were four plates and a pan in the sink at 6:30 this morning" (an observation).
The same publisher separates feelings from evaluations dressed as feelings. "I feel ignored", "I feel attacked" and "I feel manipulated" sound like feelings, but each says what the speaker thinks the other person did (a list of feelings versus evaluations masquerading as feelings). A test: if you can replace "feel" with "think" and the sentence still works, it is probably a thought. "I feel frustrated" does not pass that test, which is how you know it is a feeling. The Center for Nonviolent Communication also publishes a longer feelings and needs inventory; it sits behind a sign-up form, so we describe it and do not reproduce it. If you struggle for a word, a short list of plain ones works: annoyed, worried, embarrassed, tired, anxious, relieved, hurt.
Build the line
Put it together in three short sentences. For the dishes case:
- What happened: "Most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when I make breakfast at 6:30."
- How it affected me: "I start the day in a messy kitchen and I get stressed before my commute."
- What I would like: "I would like to find a way to have the sink clear by morning. Can we talk about what would work for you?"
The last sentence leaves the exact request for later. Making a clear request turns it into one action and a time. In the opening, an invitation to solve the problem together is often enough.
A good opening makes a good conversation more likely. It does not make the other person agree, and it does not make them change. Gordon Training, Oklahoma State and Union College each say as much about their own scripts. Where a lease, a contract or an employer's policy requires notice in writing, a conversation does not replace that notice: Neighbors, landlords and people you hired explains how to follow up in writing. If the other person has hurt or threatened you, this chapter does not apply; see When Learn Conflict Management is the wrong tool.
One issue at a time
Raise one thing. The University of Florida's extension service lists "one issue at a time" among its ten rules for constructive conflict (UF/IFAS Extension: 10 rules for constructive conflict). Utah State University's extension sheet and the Gottman Institute say the same: do not bring up a laundry list (Utah State extension on resolving conflicts) (Gottman Institute on the six skills). Convention
The reason is simple. A list of complaints tells the other person that the problem is them, not the dishes. It also gives them too many things to answer, and they will answer the easiest. If you have three disagreements, pick the one that matters most, or the one that affects the other two. Write the others in the conversation plan under a heading you will not say aloud. If the person raises another issue during the talk, you can write it down and say: "That matters. Can we take it up next, after we finish this?"
Notice when you are about to join two issues with "and also" or "another thing". The draft check counts these joins as a prompt, not a verdict.
Choose how you talk
You can open in person, by phone or video, or in writing. The right choice depends on the relationship and on whether you need a record.
For a relationship that continues and matters, we recommend talking in person or by voice. Tone, face and the chance to repair mid-sentence help. A study of young couples found that, for women, using text messages to apologize, work out differences or make decisions went with lower relationship quality (BYU News on a texting study). The study measured 276 people aged 18 to 25 in committed relationships and found associations, not causes (the journal abstract). It tells us that texting is a poor default for hard talks between partners. It does not tell us about neighbors, landlords or contractors.
Writing has its own value when a record matters. If you are dealing with a landlord, a contractor or an employer, a written message creates the dated record that your log and any later complaint depend on. Write briefly and neutrally. A Kansas State University extension sheet for co-parents suggests this test for any written message: if you would not want a judge to read it someday, revise it (K-State extension on co-parenting communication). The Federal Trade Commission's advice on home improvement jobs also leans on written records and documents (FTC on home improvement jobs). How to set that message out so it gets read is in Learn Persuasive Writing, The shape of a letter. Ask the authority
You can combine the two. Talk first, then send a short written follow-up that says what you understood. If you choose writing for the opening, paste the draft into the draft check and choose "Send it in writing", which adds the judge test as a prompt. Do not send a draft written while you were flooded; hold it until you have taken the break from Cooling down.
If you do not know yet which medium fits, write the plan for an in-person talk and decide the medium when you know whether a record will matter. Phrases has a row for each setting.
The three scripts side by side
| Script | Parts | Where it comes from | Consequence step |
|---|---|---|---|
| I-message (Gordon) | Behavior, feeling, concrete effect | Gordon Training International; the organization sells training | None |
| Extension version (Oklahoma State) | Event, feeling, what you would like, optional consequence | A fact sheet for co-parents; the consequence is mainly for children | Optional |
| DESC (Bower and Bower) | Describe, express, specify, consequences | Reproduced in a Yale handout for managers | Yes, positive and negative |
DESC, from Sharon and Gordon Bower's book Asserting Yourself, asks you to describe the behavior as completely and objectively as possible, express feelings with "I" and not "you", specify the behavior or outcome you would prefer, and state both positive and negative consequences (Yale's handout on DESC). It advises writing the script down and practicing before you speak. Our default leaves out consequences in an opening. The Oklahoma State sheet keeps them mainly for children, and in an opening they can read as a threat. When a consequence is a real, proportionate next step you will take, Making a clear request shows how to state it.
Which one to use? If you are new to this, use Gordon's three parts. If you know something about the other person's day, add Union College's empathy statement first. If a record matters, DESC's habit of writing the script down is useful.
The pronoun research, and its limits
Two studies are often cited for "use I-statements." In a study of high school students, reactions to imagined accusing "you" statements were more aversive and drew stronger antagonistic inclinations than assertive "I" statements (Kubany and colleagues 1992, abstract). In 59 couples talking about problems, more "you" went with more negativity, and more "we" with more positive solutions (Simmons and colleagues 2005, abstract).
Both studies have limits. The first asked teenagers to imagine reactions. The second looked at couples in which one spouse had an anxiety disorder, and it found associations, not causes. Neither shows that the pronoun does the work. The Gottman Institute warns that "I feel like you never listen to me" is still harsh, and we agree: the sentence is an accusation with an "I" in front. Test it The advice that holds up is to describe what happened and its effect on you. The pronoun is a tool, and not a rule.
The texting study and what it did not measure
The journal article on texting in couples (Schade and colleagues 2013) reported that, for men, texting frequency was negatively associated with satisfaction and stability for both partners, and that texting to express affection went with higher reported attachment. The finding about women and apologizing by text comes from the university's news release and not from the abstract we read. The sample was young couples, and the data were cross-sectional. We found no study comparing talk and text for neighbors, landlords or contractors.
See it: Maya and Eli See it
Maya Torres and Eli Brooks are invented for Learn Conflict Management. Maya (she/her) is a dental hygienist who shares a two-bedroom rented apartment with Eli (he/him), a line cook who works until about 11 p.m. four nights a week. They get along. Dishes sit in the sink overnight three or four nights a week, and Maya has not raised it.
Known: most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when Maya makes breakfast at 6:30; Maya leaves for work at 7:15; Eli works late four nights a week. Assumed (by Maya): Eli does not know it bothers her; he is tired after his shifts. Open: what Eli would prefer, which only Eli can say; and whether this one issue is really about dishes or also about his partner staying over, which Maya has not discussed. Maya decides which issue to raise first.
Maya's first draft: "You always leave the sink full and you never think about anyone else. It's gross." She runs it through the draft check. It lists "always" and "never", and a sentence with "you" and a judging word ("gross" is not on the list, but "think about anyone else" is a verdict on character). It finds no request and no time.
Maya rewrites it: "Most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when I make breakfast at 6:30. I start the day in a messy kitchen and I get stressed before my commute. I know you're on your feet until 11. Can we talk about what would work for both of us?" She picks Thursday evening, in the kitchen, before Eli's shift, and sends a text: "Do you have 15 minutes Thursday before you leave for work? I'd like to talk about the dishes." Eli replies with a thumbs up.
The invitation names the topic, the size of the ask and the time. The opening describes, says how it affects her, acknowledges his schedule and asks him to solve it with her. It does not yet make a request: she holds that for Making a clear request, after she has listened.
- Gottman Institute: softening your start, soft and harsh openings side by side, with a workplace example.
- Gordon Training: the three parts of an I-message, from the organization that developed it.
- Oklahoma State extension: "I" messages, with fill-in practice and a list of "you" statements to avoid.
Practice Practice
Minimum: write one opening line for your own disagreement, run it through the draft check, and fix what it lists. Time: about 30 minutes. Materials: the conversation plan, and a phone or friend if you want to say it aloud.
- Write what happened. One sentence a camera could record, with a time frame. If you have it in the plan from Sizing up a disagreement, copy it.
- Write how it affected you. One feeling word and one concrete effect, such as "I start the day stressed". Check that your feeling word is not an evaluation dressed as a feeling.
- Write what you would like. An invitation to find a solution is enough for now.
- Run the draft check. Paste the three sentences into the draft check. Fix any sentence it lists for all-or-nothing words, "you" plus a judging word, or "should".
- Say it aloud once. Time yourself. A minute is plenty. If it runs longer, cut.
- Choose a time, place and medium. Write them in the plan and send the invitation.
Rewrite three complaints. Take three complaints you have made or thought, each with "always" or "never" or a label in it. Rewrite each as an observation, an effect and an invitation. Add the three rows to the exercise list on Practice sheets. Then say the third one to a friend and ask whether it sounded like blame.
Your disagreement Your disagreement
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Could a camera have recorded the first sentence, with a time frame and no verdict?
- Does the opening say how it affected you, in a feeling word that is not a thought?
- Have you removed "always", "never", and any label for the person?
- Does it say what you would like, even if only as an invitation?
- Is it one issue, said in about a minute?
- Did you choose a time that is not right after it happened and not late at night, and a medium with a reason?
Worked example
Maya's second draft passes each criterion. A camera could have recorded "most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when I make breakfast at 6:30". The effect is stated ("I get stressed before my commute"). No all-or-nothing word or label remains. It invites a solution. It is one issue. Thursday before Eli's shift is neither right after nor months late, and the medium is in person because they live together and the relationship continues.
Common mistakes
- Starting with a question that is really a charge. "Why do you always leave this?" is a verdict. Try the observation.
- Saying only how you feel. "I'm frustrated" leaves the other person guessing what to change. Add the concrete effect.
- Dressing a thought as a feeling. "I feel like you don't respect me" says what you think they think.
- Raising three issues in one breath. Pick one.
- Sending a draft written while angry. Hold it, and take a break first.
What is still unresolved
An opening cannot tell you what the other person wants, or how they will respond. Listening so they feel heard covers the other half of the conversation. What you will ask for, specifically, is in Making a clear request. Whether the other person must do anything is set by a lease, a contract or an employer's policy, and not by how well you opened. If the talk heats up, see When it heats up.
Knowledge check and scenario
Why does a camera test help when you describe what happened?
Is "I feel that you don't care" an I-message?
When might a written opening be the better choice than talking?
(Go deeper) What do the pronoun studies show, and what do they not show?
Checklist
The chapters in this book are also published at Learn IEP Basics, Plan Your House Move and Learn Conflict Management, where the tools and record sheets they mention are kept.