Two people who have each run a home are about to run one, and each arrives with a list of things that must be so. “I need the spare room” is a position. What the room is for is the interest, and an interest can often be met some other way. Nearly every argument in this move is one of those mistaken for the other, so learn to tell them apart before anything is decided.

Before you raise it

What you want and why: positions, interests, and what you'll do if you don't agree

Separate what you are asking for from why it matters, guess at the other person's reasons as guesses, and decide what you will do if you do not agree.

Start here Essentials

This chapter asks you to write four short things on your plan: what you are asking for, why, your guesses about the other side, and what you will do if you do not agree.

  1. Write what you are asking for in one line. That is your position (Positions and interests).
  2. Under it, write why it matters to you. Ask "why" again until the answer stops changing (Finding your own interests).
  3. Write two guesses at what they want and why, and mark each one as a guess (Guessing at theirs, and checking).
  4. Write what you will do if you do not agree. Compare it fairly with what you are asking for (What you will do if you do not agree).

Minimum time: about 20 minutes. Done when: your Conversation plan has your position, at least two interests, two guesses at theirs and your fallback.

1. Positions and interests Understand

Imagine two siblings arguing about where to host their parents' anniversary party. One says it must be at her house. The other says it must be at his. Harvard's Program on Negotiation uses this case in its guide to principled negotiation. In the guide, the siblings reach an affordable restaurant once they discuss what each of them actually needs from the day (Program on Negotiation, Principled Negotiation).

The example shows two terms that run through Learn Conflict Management. A position is what you ask for: a fixed demand such as "the party must be at my house." An interest is why: the need, motivation or concern underneath the position. The Program on Negotiation credits the idea to Roger Fisher, William Ury and Bruce Patton of the Harvard Negotiation Project and their book Getting to Yes. Beyond Intractability, a project at the University of Colorado, defines interests as desires or goals and contrasts them with positions (Interests, Positions, Needs, and Values).

SituationPositionInterests it may be hiding
Housemates and dishes"Wash them before bed."A clear counter and a calm start to the morning; not feeling like the only one who notices.
A neighbor's dog"Keep the dog inside."Quiet before 7 a.m.; not being the one who has to complain.
A contractor's late job"Finish by November 7 and drop the $640."A working bathroom; no surprise charges; trust that the work is being done.
A coworker and the holiday schedule"I need that week."A flight already booked; childcare that falls through on two days.

The same table works from the other side. The person you disagree with also has a position and interests, and the interests are usually less visible to you than yours are to you.

Why positions are tempting

A position is easy to state and easy to defend. It is also easy to refuse. When both people hold positions, the conversation turns into a contest of who gives way, and it stops being a search for something that works. Interests are harder to state, because you have to know what you actually care about, and sometimes you do not. But interests are where the room for agreement is. Two opposite positions may be satisfied by one arrangement that neither person thought of.

Physical principle This is not magic. Sometimes the interests really do collide, as in a dispute over a fixed sum of money, and there is nothing to enlarge. The last section of this chapter covers those cases.

Needs and strategies

Nonviolent Communication, a method developed by Marshall Rosenberg, draws a related distinction between a need and a strategy. In the publisher's handout, a need is something required to sustain and enrich life, and it makes no reference to a specific person doing a specific thing. A strategy, such as "he should wash his dishes," does name a person and an action (The 4 Components of Nonviolent Communication). The Center for Nonviolent Communication describes needs as the conditions human beings require in order to thrive, including respect, freedom and dignity (Purpose of NVC). The Center publishes a feelings and needs inventory, which we link and describe here but do not reproduce. If you want a longer list of words to choose from, look for it on the Center's site.

In everyday disputes the line between an interest and a need is not sharp, and we use "interest" for both. The point is the same: ask what the position serves.

2. Finding your own interests

You usually know your position at once. Your interests take a little longer. The simplest method is to ask "why does this matter to me?" and answer in a sentence, then ask again of the answer, until the answer stops changing. Do it on paper. Three or four rounds is typical.

RoundMaya's answer (fictional)
PositionI want the dishes done before bed.
Why does that matter?Because I come into a messy kitchen at 6:30.
Why does that matter?Because I have 45 minutes before my commute and I want them to be calm.
Why does that matter?Because the mornings set my day, and I feel resentful by 6:45.

Maya stops when the answer is a feeling and a need rather than another demand. Her interests are a clear counter, a calm start, and not holding resentment about something she has not said. Notice that "done before bed" has dropped out. It was one way to meet the interest, not the interest itself. That opens room for other ways, such as soaking dishes in a tub, which is the arrangement she and Eli end up with.

The Gottman Institute suggests two questions when you want to complain without blame: "What do I feel?" and "What do I need?" (The Four Horsemen: The Antidotes). They help in this step too. Write the feeling in your own word, not as an accusation, and write the need as something you could get from more than one person or more than one action.

Answer separately first

If you share a home, a useful exercise is to answer the questions apart and meet afterward. Elizabethtown College's roommate agreement has each roommate complete a section independently before they meet and complete the contract together (Elizabethtown College Roommate Agreement). Georgia College's version asks "What is your definition of clean?" of each roommate separately (Georgia College roommate agreement). Answering alone first keeps one person's wording from steering the other's, and it brings out differences that would otherwise surface as arguments. At home builds on this with a household agreement.

3. Guessing at theirs, and checking

Next, write what you think the other person wants and why. This is the step that most often goes wrong, in a specific way: people write their guesses as facts. "He wants to get out of doing his share" is a guess about a motive, written as if known. A guess is useful when you label it and plan how to check it.

Write two or three guesses. For each, add two things: how you would know if it is right, and a question you could ask. For example:

  • Guess: Eli is tired after a late shift and doesn't want to wash up at midnight. Check: Ask, "What's the evening like after you get in?"
  • Guess: Eli doesn't see the sink as a problem because he washes up when he wakes. Check: Ask, "When do you usually get to the dishes?"

Try for guesses that are charitable but not naive. You do not have to believe they are right. Assuming the most generous plausible reason, and then checking, tends to keep the conversation on the issue. When your guess is that they are malicious, hold it lightly and ask what else could explain what you saw.

The questions come from the next conversation, not this one. The Mississippi State University Extension publication on addressing conflict offers a guiding question that is useful here: what goals, needs or concerns do you think need to be addressed in order to resolve this? (Understanding and Addressing Conflict). The University of Kansas Community Tool Box also advises describing your own experience rather than assigning motives (Community Tool Box, Conflict Resolution). Listening so they feel heard shows how to ask open questions that find interests, and what to do with the answers.

Preference Write the other person's interests in the plan under the label "my guesses". When you hear their real answer, cross out or correct the guess. The plan stays honest about what you knew and when.

4. What you will do if you do not agree

A conversation that goes well may still not end in agreement. Knowing in advance what you will do then makes you less likely to take a bad deal and less likely to blow up. The Program on Negotiation calls this your BATNA, a best alternative to a negotiated agreement. The name is jargon. In plain terms, as its guide says, it is what you will do if you do not reach a deal (Program on Negotiation, Translate Your BATNA). The University of Kansas Community Tool Box names the same idea in its section on exploring alternatives, crediting Roger Fisher and Danny Ertel.

In everyday terms, it is the answer to "What will I do if this does not work?" It might be:

  • Live with it and adjust (soak your own dishes and let his sit).
  • Ask for a written household agreement, or a regular house meeting.
  • Ask someone else to help the two of you talk (Getting a third party lists the kinds).
  • Take a formal step, such as a complaint, small claims, or moving out.
  • Let it go on purpose, as Sizing up a disagreement describes.

Compare fairly

The Program on Negotiation's guide gives an insurance example. A homeowner saw a replacement policy quoted at 30 percent less and thought they had a strong alternative. After comparing coverage limits, exclusions and definitions, the existing policy turned out to be better. The lesson is to put the alternative into comparable terms before you rely on it. Do the same with yours. Does "I'll move out" include the deposit, the cost of moving and the lease terms? Does "I'll file a complaint" include the time it takes and what the office can and cannot do? The point of your fallback is to tell you when to say yes and when to walk away. The Program on Negotiation says walking away from an agreement that does not beat your alternative is not a failure.

Limits

"What you will do if you do not agree" may include formal steps, such as a complaint, small claims or leaving a lease. This chapter names them as options to look up, not as advice that any of them fits your situation. Your lease, contract, employer's policy and local law decide what you can do and when. Getting a third party and Where to take it next say whom to ask. The other person's interests, in your plan, are guesses until they confirm them.

5. When interests are not enough

Looking for interests helps in many disagreements and fails in some. Three cases come up.

  • A fixed amount. If you are dividing one sum of money, a fixed supply or a single prize, there may be no way to enlarge it. Beyond Intractability says that in these disputes there may be no way to enlarge the pie. Kilmann makes a related point: he calls a dispute along one dimension, such as a wage, a poor fit for collaborating. Look for other dimensions, such as timing or conditions, but accept that you may be splitting a number.
  • Values and basic needs. The Beyond Intractability essay reports a view associated with John Burton that deep needs and values are not negotiable, and that handling them as interests to be traded can make a dispute worse. If the disagreement is about whether something is right, aim to understand and to live alongside it, not to bargain it away.
  • The other side is not willing. Interest-based talk needs two people willing to talk about interests. If one will not, your fallback matters more.

The Program on Negotiation, in its piece on expanding the pie, says many situations that look purely win-lose can become chances for mutual gain with careful questioning and listening. Note the words "can" and "careful". They describe a possibility, not a promise. We say the same, and we keep the second half of the sentence: some cannot.

Go deeper

Distributive and integrative bargaining

The Program on Negotiation separates two kinds. Distributive bargaining is win-lose negotiation, where parties compete over a fixed amount of value. Integrative bargaining, often called win-win, seeks to expand the pie before dividing it. In its example, a seller's position of $12,000 for a car hides an interest in getting funds quickly for a move (Expanding the Pie). The article also quotes Michael Wheeler of Harvard Business School: sometimes getting 70 percent of the small pie might be better than getting 50 percent of a marginally larger one. That is a caution against assuming bigger is better, and a reminder that you are allowed to want a quick, certain, smaller result.

Burton's argument about human needs

The Beyond Intractability essay summarizes John Burton's argument that deeply felt human needs are not negotiable, and that disputes over them may not be settled by trading. For an everyday disagreement the useful part is practical: if the other person treats something as a need, such as dignity, belonging or safety, trading it against convenience will sound like an insult. Ask what it protects.

Objective criteria

Principled negotiation has a fourth element beyond people, interests and options: objective criteria, meaning fair, independent standards. The key is agreeing in advance which standards apply, for example a published price or a written rule. Options and agreements teaches how to use them when you choose among options.

6. See it See it

Fictional example

Maya and Eli (invented for Learn Conflict Management). Maya Torres, 31, and Eli Brooks, 33, share a rented apartment. Eli works until about 11 p.m. four nights a week.

Known: Maya's position is "dishes washed or put away before bed." Her interests are a clear counter and a calm start before a 7:15 commute, and not carrying resentment.

Assumed (by Maya): Eli would rather not wash up at midnight after a shift. Maya wrote it as a guess and planned to ask. Eli settles it when she asks.

Open: what Eli actually wants. Eli settles it in the conversation. Maya's fallback if they do not agree: she will keep washing her own dishes, move his to a tub on the counter on mornings when it matters, and ask for a short house meeting in two weeks about a written household agreement.

Compare Maya's fallback fairly. Washing his dishes herself for two weeks costs her about ten minutes on the days she does it, and it keeps the apartment peaceful while she tests the conversation. A written agreement is a bigger step than a rule on a sticky note, and she asks only for a meeting, not a result. She does not list "move out." It is not a real alternative for the next two weeks, and she knows it.

Teresa Alvarez's plan shows the same structure at larger stakes. Her position is that the bathroom be finished by November 7 and that the $640 charge be removed. Her interests are a working bathroom, no surprise charges, and a contractor she can trust to finish. Her guesses about Ray Dunn are that something went wrong with his crew or his schedule, and that he added the $640 because he thinks a text approval was enough; she marks both as guesses and will check. Her fallback is to ask her state's attorney general's mediation unit for help. She names small claims, compares what each would cost her and how long each would take, and does not choose it. The details of her case, and where to look them up, are in Neighbors, landlords and people you hired.

For a free demonstration of the method, the Program on Negotiation's principled negotiation guide walks through the siblings' party. The University of Kansas Community Tool Box section on conflict resolution is a longer free read that covers both interests and alternatives.

7. Practice Practice

Minimum: fill in the four lines of the plan: position, interests, two guesses, fallback. Time: about 25 minutes. Materials: the Conversation plan, or paper.

  1. Write your position in one line, as an action you would like.
  2. Ask why three times. Under your position, write why it matters. Write the answer. Ask why again of the answer. Stop when the answer is a feeling or need and stops changing.
  3. Write two or three guesses about their position and interests. Mark each "guess". Beside each write one question that would check it.
  4. Write your fallback. What will you do if you do not agree? Add a rough cost in time, money and the relationship.
  5. Pick the one or two interests that matter most. These are the ones to protect in an agreement. The rest are where you can give.
Go deeper

Optional, for a household. Each person answers the same set of questions alone, then you compare. Use the household sheet in Agreement and check-ins. Compare where your answers match first, then look at where they differ. Time: about 30 minutes each, plus 20 together.

8. Your disagreement Your disagreement

9. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Is your position an action you are asking for, not a complaint or a label?
  • Do your interests answer "why", and do they stay the same when you ask again?
  • Are your guesses at their interests marked as guesses, each with a question to check?
  • Does your fallback say what you will do, with a rough comparison of what it costs?
  • Can you name the one or two interests you most need to protect?

Worked example

Maya's plan passes. The position ("dishes washed or put away before bed") is an action. The interests (a clear counter, a calm start, not carrying resentment) are feelings and needs, and they would still be there if the position changed. Her two guesses at Eli's interests are marked. Her fallback is a sequence she can do, with a cost. She picks the calm start and the resentment as the two to protect.

Common mistakes

  • Treating a position as an interest. "I want him to be more considerate" is a wish about a person. Ask what considerate would give you.
  • Writing guesses as facts. If you cannot write "I would check this by asking", you are too sure.
  • An unreal fallback. "I'll sue" or "I'll move out" can be more drama than option. Compare it with the cost.
  • Using the other person's interests as leverage. The point is to find an agreement that works for both, not to find their weak spot.

What is still unresolved

You still do not know their interests until they tell you. Listening so they feel heard is where you find out. You also do not know whether an option you list is allowed by the lease, the contract or the rules. Read the document, and see Getting a third party if you need someone to say what applies. Choosing among options by a fair standard is covered in Options and agreements.

10. Knowledge check and scenario

Two people want the same parking space. One says it is his because he pays, and the other says it is hers because she arrives first. What are the positions, and what might the interests be?
The positions are "mine" and "mine". The interests could be cost, fairness, convenience, a short walk with a heavy load, or knowing the space is there. Asking why may show that only one of them needs the space on certain days.
Why write guesses about the other person's interests?
It gives you something to check with questions, and it keeps you from treating a story as a fact. Marking them as guesses helps you hear the real answer.
What does "what you will do if you do not agree" do for you?
It tells you what a deal has to beat. It reduces the pressure to accept a bad agreement, and it keeps you from walking away from a good one because you did not know your options.
When may looking for interests not help?
When you are dividing a fixed amount, when the dispute is about deeply held values or basic needs, or when the other person is not willing to talk about interests.
(Go deeper) What does Wheeler's remark about the small pie say?
That a sure 70 percent of a small pie can be better than 50 percent of a slightly larger one. A bigger total is not necessarily the better deal.
Marcus Lee and Janelle Ford (fictional) both asked for the week of December 22 off at the clinic's front desk. Marcus writes his position as "I need the week of the 22nd," and then writes "Janelle just wants the time off to relax." What is the best next step?
It may be right, but it is a guess about motive written as fact, and acting on it can start the conversation with a mistake. Janelle's real reason, in this case, is childcare that falls through on two days.
This is the sound path. Marcus's interest may be a flight he has already booked. His guess about Janelle becomes a question: "What's the week looking like for you?" The answer can open options neither had thought of, and the plan notes what each person can give.
A rule that sounds fair to one person may not be fair to the other, and Marcus does not know the clinic's rule. Their manager has asked them to bring a plan; leading with a position closes the options that would help. It may also be wrong about authority: check what the clinic's policy says first.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.

The chapters in this book are also published at Learn Conflict Management, Learn Meal Planning, Learn Space Planning, Learn What to Keep and Learn First Home Basics, where the tools and record sheets they mention are kept.