Smaller things are decided the same way, by the space and not by the object. This chapter was written for a move to a smaller house, and fitting two kitchens into one is the same arithmetic. Measure the shelf, keep the most you use at once, and the question changes. You are no longer defending your pots. You are choosing between two pots.
What to keep when moving to a smaller house: decide against a measured space
Keeping is the one decision that has to be paid for twice, once in space and once in the move. This chapter works backward from the shelf: duplicates, the honest count of how many a household uses, and the objects cheaper to replace than to move.
Start here Essentials
Pick one room. Write down what has to go to the space it is going to, measure that space, and take things off the list until the list fits. If you are not moving, the "space it is going to" is the shelf or cupboard you decide to give that room's things; measure it and use it the same way.
- List what you want in the destination for this room. One line per item or group, with how much shelf, rod or floor it takes (keep is paid for twice).
- Check the list against the measured space. Add up the feet. If you have not measured the space, do that first (Measure the space).
- Take out the duplicates. Keep the most you use at once, not the most you own (duplicates).
- Give everything that came off the list a door. Use the six doors from How to sort a room; an object you can't route yet goes in the dated undecided box.
Minimum time: one room's list, in one sitting. Done when: the keep list for one room is written in the keep list sheet, and the total sits inside the measured space for it.
1. Keep is paid for twice Understand
Every other door in the sort is a route. Keep is the one decision that costs something, and it costs it twice: once in space at the destination, and once in the move that takes it there. A keep list is the list of what goes into one named space, with what each item measures and whether it fits. This chapter is how to build one.
If you are not moving, the second payment takes another form. Tomás Beltrán, in the examples in Learn What to Keep, has paid $148 a month for a storage unit since 2019. Whatever sits in the unit is paid for every month it sits there. Your own invoice, rent or time is the figure; the arithmetic is the same.
The method is to work from the destination backward. The shelf takes what the shelf takes. You don't ask "do I want this?" and then look for room. You ask "of everything I want, which things fit in these feet, and which things come off?" The measures come from Measure the space, and the totals come from What fits.
Marguerite Okonjo (a fictional case, below) has the numbers in the table. Her house has 196 feet of shelf and 38 feet of hanging rod. Her apartment has 54 feet of shelf and 14 feet of rod.
| Measure | House | Apartment | Surplus (house minus apartment) | Share of the house's total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelf | 196 ft | 54 ft | 142 ft | 72 percent (142 / 196) |
| Hanging rod | 38 ft | 14 ft | 24 ft | 63 percent (24 / 38) |
Read it from the apartment's side: 54 feet is a little more than a quarter of 196. That is what has to hold everything she keeps from the whole house's shelves. The basement and the garage are outside the table, and every object in them is also competing for those 54 feet or leaving.
The surplus is a total for the whole move. It is not a quota for each room. Kitchens, closets and garages don't shed at the same rate, and a number like 72 percent says nothing about how much any one room gives up. The room-by-room figures come from your own list, one room at a time. Arithmetic, not a rule
How to build a keep list for one room
- Write the allotment. Name the space that room's things are going to and its measure in feet. With no move, choose the allotment: for example, two shelves in the hall closet for the kitchen overflow.
- List the candidates. Everything you'd put there, with a measure for each, as a width, a stack height, or feet of shelf. Measure the stack, not the guess.
- Add the column. If the total is over the allotment, you are not done choosing. If it is under, the room can keep more, or leave the space empty.
- Take things off in a fixed order. Duplicates first (next section), then objects with no place you can name, then objects cheaper to replace than to move. Each of these has its own section below.
Get help measuring or carrying anything heavy, and stop before you are tired.
2. Duplicates, and the honest count
A working count is the most of one thing you use at the same time in the place you'll have. It is not the number you own, and it isn't the number you might want on an unusual day. Our preference For a household that eats at a table that seats four, the working count of everyday plates is four. A different count belongs to the occasion table, the folding table, and the guests you host a few times a year; that count is a separate line on the list, with its own measure.
To find a working count:
- Lay out every one of the thing in one place. That includes the ones in other rooms.
- Count the most in use at once. Think of an ordinary day, then of the biggest ordinary occasion in the place you'll have.
- Keep that many, plus a spare only with a reason. A reason is that the item breaks often and can't be bought quickly, or that you are short whenever one is in the wash. "I might need it" is a use that hasn't come, and the next section handles it.
Test it If you are staying in the house for a while, take out the extras of one kind and use only the working count for your next few meals or loads. Put back what you missed. If you put back nothing, the count was right.
Objects with a story attached, such as two sets of china from two grandmothers, are not duplicates in this sense. Those go to The hard things.
3. Move it or replace it
Some objects cost more to move and house than to buy again. The idea is simple and easy to overuse, so this section gives the arithmetic, the inputs it depends on, and the limit. We claim no saving. Every figure is the reader's own, and the arithmetic can say "move it" as easily as "replace it". Our preference
The question is: if this object were not here, would it be cheaper to get another one where I'm going, once the other costs are counted? Four inputs answer it.
| Input | Where it comes from | Whose figure it is |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to move it | A written estimate, or a share of a truck or rental. Divide by how many boxes' worth of space it fills. Movers price in different ways; Plan Your House Move covers how to read an estimate. | Yours, from your estimate |
| Space it takes at the destination | Your measure, in feet of shelf, rod or floor. This is not a dollar figure. Count it as a line of its own against the allotment. | Yours, measured |
| Price to get an equivalent | A listing or store price for one like it, where you are going, on the day you check. Add the trip or the delivery. | Yours, from your own check |
| Your time | Shopping, assembling, and the old one leaving by a door: sold, given or discarded. | Yours |
Compare the first with the third. If moving costs less than buying again, move it, subject to the space line. If buying again costs less, replace-later is a candidate, and you should check the limit below before you act on it. The old object still needs a door and a route. Replacing one is not a way of skipping the six doors.
Replace-later is for objects that are low in value, large in bulk and easy to buy, such as a boxed artificial tree or a plastic storage cart. It is not advice to get rid of a working object and buy a new one. Furniture, tools, appliances and anything hard to find, or worth much to you, don't belong in this arithmetic. Every figure above is yours, not ours. We state no price, no typical cost and no saving, and the answer can change with the date you check the price. Whether a purchase makes sense for your money belongs to you, not to Learn What to Keep. Ask the authority
4. Kept for a use that hasn't come
This is the hardest kind of keep: an object you haven't used in years but could. It is the one place where people reach for a rule about months. You will meet rules of the form "if you haven't used it in a set number of months, let it go." We found no source that tests one, and Learn What to Keep states no period.
One question settles most of these. Where, specifically, in the place I'm going will I use this, and what will I use if it is gone? Our preference If you can point to the place and the use, and nothing else will do the job, the object has a reason and goes on the keep list with a measure. If you can point to neither, it takes a door. If you can name a use but not a place, that is an answer too: the measured allotment has no room for it, and something on the list has to come off to make room.
A roasting pan used twice a year passes. A box of cables for a device you no longer own doesn't. Years since the last use isn't the test; a place and a use are.
Keeping for other people
Keeping an object because someone else might want it is a decision about them, not about you. It belongs to Passing things to people. Until they answer, their object is a question in the undecided box, with their name and a date. The University of Minnesota Extension notes that decisions about personal property can lead to serious family conflicts, which is the reason to ask early (UMN Extension, Who Gets Grandma's Yellow Pie Plate?).
Merging two households
Two sets of things are going into one set of space. Measure the shared destination once and give each person an allotment of it, in feet, before anyone lists anything. Count duplicates across both households together: one set of everyday plates, not two. Each person keeps their own sentimental objects in their own allotment. Where the allotments don't add up to the space, that gap is the conversation, and it is easier to have with numbers on the table. Our preference
Keeping for a hobby that may resume
Treat the hobby as a room with an allotment: a named space, a measure, and a limit. If the hobby's things don't fit in that space, the allotment is what to change or the hobby's things have to be trimmed to it. If the hobby's space is offsite, such as a storage unit, its monthly cost is a line on the same list. The question from the previous section applies: where will it be used, and when?
Furniture that will not physically enter the new place
Measure the object's widest and tallest dimensions, then every doorway, stairwell, elevator and turn between the vehicle and the room. A piece that fits the room but not the doorway doesn't fit. Learn Space Planning covers drawing the room to scale, and Plan Your House Move covers the move. Moving heavy furniture needs more than one person; get help, and stop before you are tired.
5. See it See it
Marguerite Okonjo is fictional, and the figures below marked assumed are invented for Learn What to Keep. She is moving from a four-bedroom house to a two-bedroom apartment, with eleven weeks to closing. Her surplus is in the table above.
Known: the apartment has 54 feet of shelf. She wants the china to go to someone who will use it. Assumed (Marguerite's, from the apartment's plan): 9 of those 54 feet are in the kitchen and dining area. The dining table seats four. She owns three sets of everyday dishes, nine mixing bowls and seven casserole dishes. She has a written moving estimate. Open: who gets the china (her daughter and the relatives answer that), and whether the apartment's kitchen shelf measures what the plan says (she answers that, with a tape).
| Item (assumed) | Owns | Working count | First pass, ft | After the cut, ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Everyday dishes | 3 sets | 1 set, service for 4 | 2.0 | 2.0 |
| Mixing bowls | 9 | 3 | 1.0 | 1.0 |
| Casserole dishes | 7 | 2 | 1.5 | 1.5 |
| Cookbooks | 40 | favorites | 3.0 | 1.5 |
| Baking sheets and pans | mixed | what she bakes with | 1.5 | 1.0 |
| Stand mixer and attachments | 1 | 1 | 1.5 | 1.5 |
| Total | 10.5 | 8.5 |
The first pass is 10.5 feet against 9, which is 1.5 feet over. She cuts the cookbooks to the ones she cooks from (3.0 to 1.5 feet) and trims the pans to the ones she uses (1.5 to 1.0). The total falls to 8.5 feet, which fits the 9 with half a foot spare. The china for twelve is not on the list: its door is "to a person", and who is the next question. The cookbooks that came off take doors of their own.
The replace-later check, with assumed figures (all hers: a written moving estimate that works out to $15 per box's worth of space, and prices she checked for similar items where she's going):
| Item (assumed) | Space it fills | Cost to move (space x $15) | Price to get one like it | What the figures say |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boxed 6-foot artificial tree | 4 boxes' worth | $60 | $70 | Moving costs less. The space line decides: does a closet have room? |
| Plastic 4-drawer cart | 2 boxes' worth | $30 | $20 | Replacing costs less, if she needs one. The old one still needs a door. |
Conclusion, under these assumptions: the kitchen and dining list fits, the cart is a replace-later candidate, and the tree is a move-it candidate that depends on closet space. None of this is a saving. A saving needs the price on the day she buys, the trip, and her time, none of which is in the table. The facts that settle it are her own measures and her own estimate.
- Plan Your House Move: how to read a mover's estimate, so you can turn it into a cost per box.
- Learn Space Planning: drawing the destination room to scale before you decide what fits.
- University of Minnesota Extension: Who Gets Grandma's Yellow Pie Plate?: for the objects someone else may want.
6. Practice Practice
Minimum: one cupboard or one shelf, a tape measure and the keep list sheet. Time: about 45 minutes; the time is yours, and the sheet doesn't need to be finished in one sitting. Materials: a tape measure, paper or the keep list sheet, and the measured destination (or an allotment you choose).
- Name the space and measure it. Write its width in feet. With no move, choose the shelf or cupboard you will give this room's things.
- List what you want there. One line per item or group, with its measure.
- Count the working count for anything you own more than one of. Cross out the rest on the list.
- Add the column and compare. If it is over, take things off with the question from "Kept for a use that hasn't come": where will I use this, and what will I use if it's gone?
- Check any bulky, cheap item against the four inputs. Do this only for the low-value, high-bulk, easily bought ones.
- Give every item that came off a door. Anything unsettled goes in the dated undecided box.
- Mark each remaining row "fits: yes" in the keep list sheet, with the measure.
7. Your situation Your situation
8. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Is the space named and measured, or the allotment chosen and written down?
- Does every line on the keep list have a measure, and does the total sit inside the space?
- Is each count a working count, not the number you own?
- Does every item that came off have a door or a dated question?
- If you used replace-later, did you use your own figures, and only on low-value, bulky, easily bought items?
Worked example
Marguerite's kitchen and dining list: 10.5 feet over 9 on the first pass, 8.5 feet after cutting cookbooks and pans. The space is named, every row has a measure, the counts are working counts, and the cart and the tree have been checked against her own estimate and prices. The china is deliberately not on the list.
Common mistakes
- Treating the surplus percentage as a quota. You'll notice it when a room is told to shed 72 percent regardless of what is in it.
- Counting the number owned instead of the number used. You'll notice it when the list has nine mixing bowls.
- Using replace-later on a working, valuable or hard-to-find object. You'll notice it when the item is worth more to you than its price.
- Keeping for another person without asking them. You'll notice it when the same box moves in the next move.
What is still unresolved
This chapter fits what you keep to the space. It doesn't settle who gets what you give away (Passing things to people), what a sentimental object or a collection needs (The hard things), or where the rest goes (Donating, Selling, What can't go to the thrift store). It doesn't tell you what a replacement costs; that is your own check.
9. Knowledge check and scenario
Why does working backward from the shelf make keep decisions easier than asking "do I want this?"
A household owns nine mixing bowls and uses three at a time. What is the working count, and what happens to the other six?
Why does Learn What to Keep give no period, such as twelve months, for objects you haven't used?
(Go deeper) Two people are merging households into one apartment. What do you settle before anyone lists anything?
Checklist
The chapters in this book are also published at Learn Conflict Management, Learn Meal Planning, Learn Space Planning, Learn What to Keep and Learn First Home Basics, where the tools and record sheets they mention are kept.